ch3co3h

之前翻找电影的时候,突然脑子里跳出「云图」这个名字。印象中这是一部年代久远并且带有艰深晦涩气息的电影。其实真要说起来,这个名字并不是多年未见——Rick and Morty 里就出现过,所以这电影也许很值得一看。我倒是惊讶居然这么多年自己都没有找来看一下。

看完这部电影的结果是,我立刻下单了电子版原著小说。最近终于将小说看完,正在看第二遍。

在评价《降临》时我产生一个想法:大约小说改编电影都是不值得看的。因为电影比较难把握遵从原著与自我创新之间的平衡。但《云图》电影却做得很好。它删除或简化很多情节,制造了很多更适合银幕放映的画面。我想,一方面这体现出导演团队的才能;另一方面也是原著写得极其精彩。小说内容形式多样,文风多变,就像在读者面前铺开一幅幅美妙画卷。这样的内容直接照搬做成视频,是相当顺畅的。

导演团队中有两位沃卓斯基,就是导演了《黑客帝国》,曾经是兄弟而今是姐妹的沃卓斯基。我看到影片简介中,有两位导演的话,她们表示拍摄些深奥难懂的内容是很好的常识,观众会沉迷于解读这些深奥,而使《云图》获得成功。就像《黑客帝国》也非常难懂,但它却获得现象级成功。

假如导演当真有过如此描述,那显然是想得太好。《黑客帝国》的成功恐怕跟它的复杂深意关系并不大,毕竟大多数人都没有计算机科学知识背景,也对古代神话并不特别清楚。我想,它的流行还是与当时先进技术制造的刺激场面、明星们帅气脸庞以及部分儿童不宜镜头有关。当然《黑客帝国》本身也讲述了一个精彩的故事。而《云图》相比之下则少了些要素,显得更加平淡。正如它的名字——天空中的云虽形态多样,变幻莫测,但整体节奏是比较慢的。原著小说里每个故事只被分割成两份,而电影必须将六个故事不停交替穿插,试图维持观众亢奋的状态。

我大概是第一次看过同一部作品的影视版与原著小说。现在的感受是:电影无论时长多久,表现的有多么高端且深邃,同文字比起来,仍然是短暂而快速的刺激。电影或许能够讲述一个精彩的故事,展示一个奇幻的构思,精巧的设计,但要说深刻思考,那还是只有文字才能做到。至于《云图》这部小说究竟试图交待什么信息,作者在传达何种感悟,我现在是不太敢说的。因为我看的是译作。从原文到译作,信息恐怕要丢失百分之六、七十。但我又没能力去看英文原文,只好试着胡乱说说。毕竟本文的标题还是《〈云图〉读后感》。就像是高考答卷,哪怕不知道标准答案,还是要尽量多写点内容。

我对原著小说的感悟和看完《凯尔经的秘密》有些相似,仍旧是对人类文明进步之感慨。文明进步源于思想解放,除去历史上纯粹的知识与技术的部分,是什么去除人类的兽性?是什么让我们不断追求自由、平等、尊严及美好?是什么拯救了我们的生命,又是什么值得我们甘愿放弃生命?我们人类应该从自身的经历中学到些什么,从而选择去信仰些什么?我想这部小说给出了完美的答案。

当整个社会上所有人都认定的低端愚昧种族的一员散发着人性的光辉,而同类的高贵种族却将他们的贪婪、丑恶、低俗与堕落暴露无余,目睹这些的你是否会在某个瞬间产生顿悟,明白人该当生而平等。当拥有卓绝才华的人进行创作试图为全人类留下一份宝贵遗产时,是谁因嫉恨而阻挠其事,迫害其人,我们能否对超人之才尽量多些宽容?……

如果一个人真能从这六个故事中读出些味来,我觉得他会试着从现在起多关注一点人类的历史,多思考一分当下,去思考权利与义务,合理与不合理,去感悟生存的价值与自由的意义。也许某个时刻,我们也能像先贤鲁迅先生那样发出振聋发聩的提问:从来如此,便对么?

2022 年 6 月 29 日

Original broadcast date: September 3, 2021

Food is one of life's greatest pleasures, yet many of our food systems are flawed. This hour, TED speakers look to the past to reconnect with what we eat, and the present to reimagine our food future.

Guests include forager Alexis Nikole Nelson, chef Sean Sherman, social entrepreneur Jasmine Crowe, and environmental journalist Amanda Little.

This episode of the TED Radio Hour was produced by Katie Monteleone, Rachel Faulkner, Diba Mohtasham, Sylvie Douglis, and Fiona Geiran. It was edited by Sanaz Meshkinpour and James Delahoussayee.

Our production staff also includes Matthew Cloutier and Margaret Cirino. Our audio engineer is Daniel Shukhin.

Hey it's Manoush. And I know some people love to cook, I just love to eat which is partly why I loved making the episode that we've got for you today. It is called the food connection and we visit with a forager who is huge on Instagram you may know her, a chef who only uses ingredients indigenous to North America and a farmer who thinks of his hi-tech organic farm as his own agricultural Wakanda. We also talked to lots of other people it is an awesome episode that first aired back in September. So I hope you enjoy it again or for the first time and I will be back next week with an all new episode. Until then take care. Thanks for being here.


I'm Manoush Zomorodi. And today we are starting the show outside foraging for food.

I have been searching this whole city and I finally found them.

This is Alexis Nikole Nelson.

And I am a forager “..., Let's go make next.” which is a fun way to say I eat plants that do not belong to me and I teach people how do the same thing.

Coolest job title ever.

Eat more batteries in Central Park.

Alexis is best known on tick tock where she has over 2000000 followers.

We are making ... coffee.

And it's kind of a foraging legend.

... Your neighbors will probably thank you.

For those who haven't seen Alexis's work, her videos are all about her foraging adventures, finding cool plants teaching people all about them and then using them to cook amazingly delicious dishes.

Yeah. There's a lot of. Little dating. There's a lot of it could be fun facts and little jokes for years very a lot of yelling about plants and flowers.

You see yelling but actually it was more just like hyped up enthusiasm right?

Thank you those are my time there were. So sweet. Happy foraging. Don't die.

So when you forage Alexis like you walk into your backyard or into a forest and what do you see the gas most of us don't it's like a supermarket basically for you.

It's like Disney world, but plants and full of much cheaper. You walk in and you see this very vibrance ecosystem but like we are a part of and there's something soulful felling about it right? you're just like I pulled this out of the ground and now it's. Yeah. Food is a way to connect with other people; food is a way to express love; food as a way to express creativity I think I look into natural spaces and I just see wonder.

Food, it's a basic need and one of life's greatest pleasures, but for many accessing nutritious and affordable food isn't always easy.

We have nearly 50000000 people that are living food insecure which means they never know when or where their next meal is coming from.

And on top of that the ways we produce and consume food are harming the planet.

Human population has doubled in the last 50 years and meat consumption has tripled.

How can we produce enough good food for a growing global population.

I think that was the best place to start was just opening up my eyes and starting to see the world around me for what I have to offer.

we need solutions to secure our food for the future and reconnect with the land that feeds us. So today on the show the food connection. Ideas from people who are taking lessons from the past and others who are experimenting with new technologies to change the way we eat. For Alexis Nikole Nelson collecting ingredients out in nature has helped her reconnect to her food she first discovered foraging when she was just 5 years old.

I remember gardening with my mother at the house I grew up in, and this one day stands out in my mind. When asked me probably not helping at all and we speak out some grass in our yard that looks different than all of the other grass which until she pointed out to me I had never noticed so my mom tells me to go and bring some for her. I break it and suddenly it's the like perfumed with garlic and she's like that is onion grass you know how we sometimes cook with like green onions you can cook with that too. And warning if you tell a 5 year old that they will just start breaking plants in her yard and seeing if a magical smells emanate from them

And eating them yes okay so your mom was very into plants clearly did you get your love of food and gardening and the outdoors from your parents do you think?

Oh absolutely. So on my dad's side of the family his mom is also have indigenous ancestry Iroquois ancestry so he was just being exposed to food way is that some of his peers work necessarily while he was a kid while he was a teenager and my dad's excellent in the kitchen and it was really this kind of coming together of the 2 things that I enjoyed doing with my parents the most as a kid and I'm very lucky to be a black kid who grew up with 2 black parents who were also very outdoorsy, because not all of us get it there really is kind of like a there's been this cultural separation between a lot of black folks and the outdoors

but historically there was no separation right and you have been studying just what happened can you explain?

Yeah, absolutely, 100%. So back especially in the south while a lot of black folks were still enslaved there was a whole lot of kind of knowledge training between black folks in indigenous folks and and a lot of the southern states and a lot of like the midwestern and northern states to and for a lot of people who were enslaved the way that you beefed up like the meager meals or the scraps but you were given was often by supplementing with foraging with trapping with fashion so that was the knowledge that was a huge part of like only black culture here in the Americas. After they were emancipated suddenly laws were getting put in place very rapidly about only being able to kind of reap the benefits of land that you owned. And if you were newly freed, odds are you do not own land. so if you can hunt you forage on public property and don't yet have private property to your name. Boom! That is a part of your life that you are not partaking in anymore and it doesn't take a whole lot of generations past saying for that knowledge to just kind of fall away completely.

Huh. And is this true than that like when there was an opportunity to go foraging it was kind of like well I don't have the handed down knowledge and anyway only poor people would do that.

Yeah I then you got this really weird thing happened on the twentieth century it where everyone is like wanting to show off well so then foraging kind of became taboo even if you did have the knowledge and that was regardless of race. Foraging very much got looked down upon because why would you be you know heading down to the creek together pop because when you can go to the grocery store and get a banana. And in the 1950s and 1960s being a black person out in nature out in the woods out in predominately white spaces like a very scary thing to do. For the sake of your safety that like that's not a space that you would want to necessarily be. And it was kind of like a 3 combo punch to us culturally moving away. From getting to know our natural spaces, and I am one of a myriad of people who's actively trying to combat that.

And do you feel like it's working like what kind of feedback do you get from your followers

yeah I. One of the best days I think I've ever had in my life I was out forging and a girl who also happens to be black probably teenager. She runs up to me and she's like you are that girl from tiktok. I was like oh my god. Yes and she was so excited when I got to like take her and show her what I was there harvesting I got to give her and her mom like a cut leaf to thwart leave so they can taste like the spicy brassica emails from it. And the wave of her and like her friends and her mom's like face lit up. I went home and I cried. I cried for like a solid 20 minutes because that's ... Oh my gosh it's almost overwhelming in. And the thing that stuck with me was she was just like you're doing this for the culture. I'm starting to tear up just thinking about it now.

In some ways through forging you are helping people reconnect with their own history and the ways that people use to eat off the land like in a seasonal sustainable way.

Yeah. So many of us have such a fraught relationship with food. And a lot of that is due in part to like societal pressures a lot of that is due to how processed food is and I personally I have had a historically very fraught relationship with food I grew up very over weights and so I was always being pressured to eat last cut last I. Our full disclosure like dealt with an eating disorder and my early in my mid twenties and which food was like very much the enemy in which I had to like train myself to stop thinking about this subject that I had loved thinking about and dreaming about my entire childhood and in a way diving back into foraging. Was the way that I fell back. “... Also known as the June.” It was not on purpose I was super poor after college. Living in a house with 5 of my friends and wanting to eat things other than Raman and canned vegetables. And sounds like a well you know let me turn to some of that like beard. Knowledge. But I've just been amassing for no reason as a kid. And it just brought me this show Wayne. And that's like connection to place. But I didn't have at that point in time. So much so that I went out and I sought out more information and I got more balls with my cooking and you know started being willing to put like flour and bread to my food again you know I was willing to make sweet things again I just... there's something soul nourishing about caring about what you're nourishing your body with.

That's forger Alexis Nikole Nelson you can find her on tick tock at Alexis Nicole and on Instagram and Twitter at black forager. On the show today the food connection. I'm a new summer roadie and you're listening to the Ted radio hour from NPR. Stay with us.


In stressful times you want to spend your time checking out not just what's best what's best for you. We know you care about what you watch what you read and what you listen to NPR's pop culture happy hour podcast is with you 5 days a week to make sure that time is well spent listen now to the pop culture happy hour podcast from NPR.

It's the Ted radio hour from NPR I'm Manoush Zomorodi. On the show today, the food connection. If you visited Sean Sherman's restaurant Awani in Minneapolis you will find a pretty unique menu.

So we've got a lot of documenting keys pheasant venison and elk things like that.

Dishes like preserved rabbit bison tartare.

Lots of wonderful lake fish from across this region and around the Great Lakes.

Grilled root vegetables with dandelion pesto and hand harvested wild rice.

We have many varietals of corn beans lots of wild berries lots of wild foods in general says a lot of cedar there's a lot of burger month things like that.

But what you won't find anything that isn't native to North America.

We cut out colonial ingredients and things that didn't exist here before so we don't use any Terry any wheat flour and cane sugar and we're not using beef pork or chicken for protein choices so we just try to cook and make food taste like where we are and get people to think about the history of the land that they're standing on.

Sean is a restaurant owner chef and the founder and CEO of the company the SIOUX chef

as an S. I. O. U. accents I'm a part of the Ogallala Lakota Sioux tribe.

when I called John on a Monday the restaurant was closed but he was prepping for the weekend. Okay so what are you doing what are you cooking right now.

so we've got a big pot of choke cherries today that my mom brought to the restaurant and she was just in the black hills and I was probably cooking about 20 pounds a choke cherries not that smell of wild choke cherries cooking just to something that I always just shoots me back to being a young kid in my grandmother's kitchen.

Sean ... sounds unlike any restaurant I have ever been to and that is kind of the point right?

It is you know can that's kind of unfortunate that we're now one of the only restaurants of this kind out there it opens up a lot of conversation you know it opens up that question why aren't there more native restaurants out there. And it does start with history I mean it's just the relations of indigenous peoples and primarily the United States government you know it's going to be important overall to know these pieces of history that have happened to us and have really kept us down for a long time.

Here's more from Sean Sherman on the Ted stage.

I think what's most damaging for us and why we don't have a lot of indigenous restaurants out there was a loss of our education because this whole generation like my great grandfather's generation my grandfather's generation they should have been learning everything their ancestors intended them to learn you know how to fish how to hunt how to gather how to identify plants how to live sustainably utilizing plants and animals around us. But instead we went through a really intense assimilation period the boarding school systems stripped this whole generation of all that knowledge and education and we're still reeling from that and our communities today because of this direct link to the trauma that happened there. And being indigenous in the 19 hundreds of the much better my grandparents were born before they're even citizens which doesn't happen to 1924 we couldn't vote in 1965 we can celebrate religions until 78 you know. so what does it look like for me growing up in the city like I was born in the mid seventies and growing up in post colonial America like what kind of foods was I eating people in the media is like your native like what kind of food you grew up with 7 here cool story like I'd get up in the morning take down an elk with a sling shot I made it have a big family feast you know. But that wasn't the reality you know because like I grew up with a commodity food program because we're poor like a lot of people on the reservation, and it's just the way it was and we didn't have the pretty cans when I was growing up we just had these like black and white Kansas beef and uses that's dinner you know and that sucks. We could do better than this is so much more to learn and more to offer with indigenous foods.

Sean just one that emphasizes this point that as you say indigenous foods like the ones you are serving today in your restaurant they weren't really around when you were growing up on the Pine Ridge reservation.

Yep, we did harvest things like this wild prairie turn up a call that we called him so and choke cherries and there were some elders that have held on to some recipes but a lot of it was colonized I remember my mom giving me of cookbooks like we already have a cookbook featuring all the Lakota foods and it just kind of read like a Lutheran cookbook so it's just like no mom looking for recipes without cream of mushroom soup you know. So I wanted to know like what kind of wild foods were utilizing so it just was a long path of self study to try and figure it out because they're you know was no joy of native American cooking out there for me.

So so where did you turn to is the your sources for information about this it was it people was it I don't know, archives

Yeah a little bit of everything you know because I would just talk to people some of their memories try to filter what might've been indigenous and what was up obviously brought on later spent a lot of time outdoors and really just trying to understand what are the purpose of all these plants are my ancestors would have known you know the food is that medicine can craft with it or can you do all 3 and I think that was the best place to start was just opening up my eyes and starting to see the world around me for what I had to offer.

So you run the restaurant but you also founded something called the indigenous food lab where your goal is to teach people the fundamentals of indigenous food education what are those fundamentals?

So I think the first thing that you do is just identify what does the term indigenous education means, so to break down that first off indigenous education was thousands of generations of knowledge being handed down family member after family member community after community giving people the basically the blueprint to live sustainably utilizing plants and animals of your region and all the tradition that goes along with it. And understand the immense amount of diversity out there because indigenous peoples obviously isn't one group you know they're still 576 tribes federally recognized the U.S. 6 or 22 in Canada 20 percent Mexico identifying as indigenous. So when we're breaking down indigenous knowledge were looking at the wild foods permaculture agriculture seed saving regional histories medicines food preservation fermentation nutrition health spirituality and sustainability cooking techniques like it just goes on and on like it's a whole education because that's what all of our educations were, and you know we have a community garden that we do our selves are growing a lot of heirloom seed varietals whether they're corns beans squash amaranth tobacco Chiles and our goal is really utilizing our food lab as a place where tribal communities especially around us can work with us so we can help them develop healthy indigenous Connery projects for the community and share a lot of this knowledge base and education with their own community too and just help grow.

That's why we should have made American food restaurants all over the nation run by indigenous peoples right? and for us we just want to get this food back into tribal communities especially make people healthy and happy and break a lot of the cycle of you know government reliance on food and huge rates of type 2 diabetes and obesity and heart disease because of this low nutritional food based at the government's been beating us for too long. Indigenous diet is really kind of the most ideal diet of healthy fats its diverse proteins as low carbs low salt it's a ton of plant diversity and a seasonal you know this is really good it's like what the paleo diet wishes it was really when it comes to it I think because it just makes sense you know if we can control our food we can control our future and for us it's an exciting time to be indigenous because we are taking all of these lessons from our ancestors that should have been passed down to us re-learning them and utilizing the world today with everything it has to offer and becoming something different you know. This is an indigenous evolution and revolution at the same time.

You have said, Sean, in the past that sharing culture through food is healing. What do you mean by that?

I think that you know again like it just opens up people so if you think of the first time you maybe have experienced a sushi or Ethiopian food or something like that and how that affected you the flavors and you know the thoughts and how it changed your perception of that country or that culture of whatever it might be and it creates curiosity and you want to know more and you want to learn more and I think that for indigenous peoples with such a rough time especially with the US government and we've had so much stripped away from us that is really important to experience some of these players that are true representation of where we are. If you can taste these foods and have places to taste them and understand it's gonna open up a lot more people for compassion understanding and you know we can live in a better world.

That's Sean Sherman, co-owner of a whiny in Minneapolis and founder of the sous chef you can see his full talk at Ted.com. On the show today ideas on reconnecting to what we eat. And solutions for some of our biggest food problems which includes hunger.

There's a lot that has to do with just access which is why I have always said that hunger is not an issue of scarcity there's more than enough food.

This is social entrepreneur jasmine Crowe for the last 4 years she's been trying to figure out how to re direct healthy food that might be wasted to the people who need it. Ever since she visited a food bank in 2017 and saw what was on offer.

I always remember the biggest thing is they were giving away a gallon of barbecue sauce. I just think like a whole gallon of milk but it's filled with barbecue sauce, and they know me. They had weight watchers Johnson's belvita breakfast biscuits they're really super hero shaped macaroni noodles. Love can get like a very small can of corn can of peas cantor refried beans and cattle potato chips French fries green onions that's what they were given people that was it. Nothing was fresh, nothing made sense I connect think that someone would be able to take those items home and actually make a meal of them. I learned that it was ultimately the case from lack of food banks and a lot of food pantries they would receive donations of whatever it was gonna be that week and that's what it was and what I saw that that was doing it it made people have to go to a lot of different food banks because they never knew what they were thinking. It to me was a real eye opening experience and there being a huge difference in this country between access to food and access to meals.

So jasmine started to investigate why food banks weren't solving the US's hunger problem. She continues from the Ted stage.

And almost every major US city the food bank is viewed as a beloved community institution. Co-operations and volunteers down on a weekly basis to sort through food items and make boxes of food for the needy. Can't drive they warm the hearts of schools and office buildings that participate in fill the shelves of food banks and food pantries across the nation. This is how it works and hunger and what I've come to realize is that we are doing hunger off. We've created a cycle that keeps people dependent on food banks and pantries on a monthly basis for food that is often not well balance is certainly doesn't provide them with a healthy now yeah we're wasting more food than ever before more than 80 billion pounds a year to be exact and as this food 6 he gradually rocks introduces harmful methane gas a leading contributor to global climate change yep the waste of the food itself the waste of all the money associated with producing this now wasted food and a waste of labor with all of the above all of this made me realize that hunger was not an issue a security. But rather a matter of logistics.

I mean Jasmine that is staggering I can't even picture how much 80 billion pounds of food like what does that even look like we are asking so much every year.

And I want to stress that this is not food that's also coming from our households could if you factor that number and it's even greater but for a consumer facing businesses every year 80000000000 pounds a perfectly good food goes to waste. So these are the restaurants these at the grocery store she go to the hotels all that food gets thrown away while at the same time we have nearly 50 million people that are living food insecure which means they never know when or where their next meal is coming from. I just couldn't believe that we were living in a society that was allowing that to happen all those things combined ultimately led me to start this company. So in 2017 I created an app that would inventory of a thing it is a business house and make it super easy for them to donate this excess food that would typically go to waste at the end of the night. All the end user has to do now is click on an item tell us how many they have to donate and I platform calculates the weight in the tax value of those items at time of donation within connect with local drivers in the shared economy to get this food picked up and delivered directly to the door of the nonprofit organizations and people in need. I provided the data and analytics to help businesses reduce food waste at the source and even save millions of dollars our mission was simple: feed more waste less. And by 2018 our clients include the world's busiest airport Atlanta's Hartsfield Jackson core mount chick fillet in Papa Johns who worked with over 200 business is to divert more than 2000000 pounds of edible food from landfills into the hands of people that need it most.

So you create this company, you build an app and you do well for a few years but as we've seen the pandemic up and did all kinds of supply chains and particularly magnified the vulnerabilities in our food systems. Did you need to change how you run your business as a result?

So the apps still exists but what we did in TNTN is we made a picnic a lot of the businesses that we were serving have closed their doors airports convention centers stadiums and arenas colleges and universities so when I started thinking is how can we be the helpers? Our first big customer was actually won the public school districts in Atlanta where they were somewhere near 50000 students that were the bus to school everyday again logistics and at school they receive breakfast and lunch so that's where they were eating and now when schools are closing how are these kids going to get access to their food and so we're good came in and did is we started delivering food directly to the students homes within took that same concept and we start working directly with food distributors and manufacturers purchasing food at cost and then delivering a involved to seniors across the city.

So rather than take excess food or wasted food and make sure it gets to people who need it you are actually buying the food that people need.

In one segment of our business yes, but we are also buying food from distributors and manufacturers that would otherwise go to waste or that they can no longer sell. We're really helping to make sure that food doesn't go to waste at the manufacturer and distributor side we're also still helping businesses address food waste and at the end of the day we're making sure that people have access to food at no cost to them. In 2016 France became the first country to ban supermarkets from throwing away unused food instead they must donate it and are fine if they don't. Denmark now has a mandated food waste grocery store its name Wefood they recover excess food from local grocery stores and sell it up to a 50 percent off discount dating is all the proceeds and donated to emergency aid programs and social media she is for the people in need and last year the world got its first pay what you can grocery store what did it for an open in Toronto their shelves remained stocked recovering excess food from major supermarkets in allowing families to simply pay what they can at the grocery store. This innovation we need more of them.

Hearing you give examples from other countries makes me wonder where the U. S. government is in all of this like why isn't this systemic solution our city officials reaching out to you and saying jasmine how can we put you out of business I mean why do you have to start a company to solve what it sounds like we need laws for?

I agree she I think 100 percent it should be a systemic solution acting last year should have lifted the veil off of everybody's eyes of the plight of hunger in this country and just how close to being hungry a lot of people are. when you asked me how many people and and policy decision makers have reached out to me and asked how can they help the reality is none. I've been waiting for one city they say let's make sure that we have food hubs that exists where Manley's know they can go and get meals for their family if they're missing a little bit of money we need less food dancers we need more affordable grocery stores; we need more people to have access to snap we have to understand inflation is happening right until we get CD's and more governments involved in actually trying to solve these problems we're going to continue to have a hunger problem.

That's social entrepreneur Jasmine Crowe she is the founder and CEO of glitter and you can see her full talk at Ted.com on the show today the food connection I'm Manoush Zomorodi and you're listening to the Ted radio hour from NPR.

It's the Ted radio hour from NPR I'm Manoush Zomorodi. On the show today the food connection we've heard about a tiktok influencer making a personal change to her diet and indigenous chef bringing the old ways of eating back to the dinner table and an entrepreneur who wants to make sure good food isn't wasted. but with so many people and the planet that so maxed out how will we be able to produce enough food in decades to come on a global scale what is the future of our food.

We have a growing global population we have growing demand for meat we also have a decreasing arable land we have increasingly brittle and antiquated food supply chains and all of this is combined with these increasing climate pressures and there has to be a new approach.

This is journalist Amanda Little and like a lot of us she's trying to make ethical food choices for herself

I live in Nashville Tennessee land of barbecues I am a shark in charmed waters and it has been very hard for me to remove meat from my diet

and that's just 1 reason why Amanda wrote a book called the feet of food it's an investigation into what needs to happen to prevent future food emergencies the international panel on climate change he said that by mid century the world may reach a threshold of global warming beyond which current agricultural practices will no longer support large human civilizations and I've committed that to memory it's an actual quote from a 2014 IPCC report because it's just such a staggering. Statement

When you put it like this I mean a like part of me is like oh my gosh it's enough to want to turn off the radio and cry but I don't want people to do that because you you know you've spent all these years traveling and talking to people who are trying to fix it.

Yeah this is a deeply troubling story how do you feed the world this is a question that has propelled and troubled civilization for the better part of 13000 years right and you have one side saying let's go back to the way things were industrial farming screwed everything up. You know we we need to D. in fact our food supply and go back to sort of pre industrial agriculture.

Those are folks who are composting and sort of going back to the land and no pesticides those sorts of things?

Yes so they want to return to this sort of pre green revolution organic biodynamic regenerative farming practices and then you have on the other side of the techno optimists who are saying food is right for reinvention right? Let's let's throw technology at this problem and then you have this other side to saying oh no no no I'd like my food de-invented thank you very much we've seen how technology has caused this problem why would we bring more technology to bear

So you've got the techno optimists on one side and then opposing them is a kind of back to the land camp

yes and I as a sort of detached observer of all this and not someone who had a dog in either fight was really perplexed like why is it one or the other. The rift between the reinvention Campa de invention campus existed for decades but now it's a raging battle.

Amanda little continues in her Ted talk.

One side covers the past the other side covers the future and if someone observing this from the outside I began to wonder why must it be so binary. Can't there be a synthesis of the 2 approaches our challenge is to borrow from the wisdom of the ages and from our most advanced science to forge this third way one that allows us to improve and scale our harvests while restoring rather than degrading the underlying web of life. I belong to neither camp. I'm a failed vegan and allow for the tarian and a terrible backyard farmer if I'm honest I will keep trying at this but I may fail. But I'm hellbent on hope and if my travels have taught me anything it's that there's good reason for hope. Farmers and entrepreneurs and academics are radically rethinking national and global food systems they're marrying principles of Old World agroecology and state of the art technologies to create what I call a third way toward food future.

So what is the sort of third way this this middle ground.

The middle ground is to find a synthesis of the traditional and the radically new the answer to food security is not technology alone and it's not traditionalism alone but its technology combined with the wisdom of a country right its technology in cooperation not competition with the natural world it is kind of theoretical as that sounds there were so many examples of innovators who really bearing this out.

One of those innovators who is a farmer named Chris. When we called Chris he just corralled some of his run away house.

Rains crazy things happen all right special it hasn't rained for a while so they wanted and nice to get the model wrote share finds out

So Chris and his partner Anne Newman are to farmers in the northern neck of Virginia.

We farmed the land at Stratford hall which gets its claim to fame is being the the press plays Robert E. Lee which is about a place for a black party farming but we have an opportunity to be on this landscape and to pursue black and indigenous led to sovereignty from here.

I first encountered Chris through his writing, he's been chronicling his own adventures as a new entrepreneurial farmer who has come up against a lot of that profound hypocrisies in a sustainable food production. And he wrote this manifesto clean food if you want to save the world get over yourself.

By get over yourself Chris means that organic farmers need to be less precious about their methods they need to embrace new ways of growing healthy food that everyone can afford.

I grew up around poverty and grew up around people who were food insecure and who were financially secure in this movement is never going to gain traction or take off or become a mass movement if we're not appealing beyond people who are in the luxury sector.

To make his food more affordable Chris uses old and new tools to farm.

His farm is really fascinating blend of traditional of approaches to farming and technology and the more time I spent with Chris and Annie the more I began to see what you know they describe is this kind of personal Wakanda this this rich forest ecosystem that he imagines will be managed intended by intelligent machines by robotic harvesters. A police where technology exists to serve and elevate nature he has you know drones and electrical fences for managed grazing and cameras and software. But what he really envisions is weaving together on these old forms of agroecology of food forests of crop production of livestock production in harmony with the natural world in harmony with ecosystems along side technologies that can help him scale his enterprise and make it possible for him to produce his food for more people more affordably.

Amanda traveled the country and the world meeting dozens of pioneers working toward this third way approach in Arkansas she witnessed the maiden voyage of an army of weed destroying robot.

I had the sense that this robot was going to look like C-3PO like some glittering gold battalion of C-3PO's to see marching out of the fields and have little pincers and it'd be plucking weeds from the ground but in fact it was this big sort of hoop skirt on the back of a tractor under which there was a bank of 24 cameras using computer vision, and the computers could distinguish between the crops and the weeds. And in a fraction of the time it takes you to blink these computers deployed with a tiny little jet a squirt of concentrated fertilizer that's too strong for a baby we to tolerate, but spare the plant itself. And so this intelligent reader has the potential to cut the use of agricultural chemicals by up to 90 percent or more.

I mean you mentioned in your book that in 2017 the guy who develop these robots gore Hey Harad that he sold his company to the tractor company John Deere the bad deal raise some eyebrows?

Yeah my question to him was your you know a paradigm shift you're a disruptor why are you selling out to the old guys? And he said because we need to scale because we need to get these things out into the field because they're great at building really good machines and we have no time to waste. Harada is the embodiment of third way thinking right? Robots he told me don't have to remove us from nature they can bring us closer to it they can restore it. Increasing crop diversity will be crucial to building resilient food systems and so will the centralizing agriculture so that when farmers in one region are disrupted the others around you can keep growing here again we see innovators borrowing from and perhaps even elevating the wisdom of natural ecosystems development in plant based and alternative meats are also profoundly hopeful. boom of the lady fed me my first plate of lab grown duck breast harvested fresh from a bioreactor. It even grown from a small sampling of cells taken from muscle tissue and fat and connective tissues which is exactly what we eat when we eat meat. This lab grown herbs Celebes duck meat has very little threat of bacterial contamination it's about 85 percent lower CO2 emissions associated with it eventually could be grown in decentralized facilities that are vulnerable to supply chain disruptions the lady started out as a cardiologist who understood the doctors have been developing human and animal tissues and laboratories for decades he was inspired as much by that is he was born in 1931 quote from Winston Churchill that says we shall escape the absurdity of growing a whole chicken in order to eat the breast of the wing. by rolling them separately insurable mediums. like corrode Valenti is a quintessential third way thinker he's re imagine an old idea using new technologie to usher in a solution whose time has come.

This is some futuristic meet Amanda okay just to be clear though they take cells from animals they culture them and then grow these cells in a lab into meat that you got to taste.

I did I tasted it duck breast which had just been produced in a bioreactor and a bioreactor is like a giant to sophisticated crock pot it basically creates a sort of warm environment in which these growing cells can can replicate and they pulled it out and their company shaft put a little salt and pepper and a little oil in a pan and mash the thing into a little meatball and sizzle that in the frying pan and it smelled like meats and and I'm going oh my gosh what have I got myself into in part because I had just signed a document that said this is an experimental product is not the the eggs that is not been approved by the FDA and what you're after yeah but what was so moving was that the lady said to me as I was sort of bit digging into this bioreactor meatball. He said you are participating in history we are working on this to change the lives of billions of humans and trillions of animals. welcome to a paradigm shift and then I said thank you thank you I can't think of a better a better grace. This feels very but you know profound and moving. And I write as I was digging into this thing with my knife and he said no no no pick it up and pry it apart with your fingers you can see the the the texture of this which I thought was so interesting I mean it I've never been encouraged to you know pick up my meat and rip it apart and what was it like well at first it was a little bit like a sort of rubber ball and I was it was kind of thinking I'm not sure what you're getting at here the but as I pulled it apart I saw the striated layers of muscle that clung to each other and pulled apart just as you pull apart the meat on a chicken breast so I pull off this little chunk and start chewing it and it was a whole different experience than an impossible burger or a beyond meat burger or certainly a black bean burger. it was meat.

You write in the book that you keep wondering what will be on the table when you hopefully visit your grand kids for thanksgiving dinner in the year 2050. What do you think that meal might look like?

Yeah I you know I spent all this time roaming around the world trying to find an answer to this question, and I arrived at. I think I probably inappropriate request which was to spend it with Chris and Annie Newman.

I would love for Amanda to to be able to come to our thanksgiving and it's like a week long thing where people who participate in the eating part of thanksgiving also participate in the vision part. You know, lots of nontraditional foods are prepared by all the hands that are at that table and I would love to be a real real big dance able

I love the possibility of eating at christen Anne's table because they want their farm to be honoring and producing the full spectrum of foods that are a part of his in Anne's family tradition Turkey and doc heirloom varieties of corn and green beans and potato grown at the margins of their food forests sauces of cranberry and elderberry and the plants of Chriss Piscopo in ancestors pawpaw persimmon chestnuts but every element will have been made possible by the next level technologies that he plans to bring into his farm you know it's not so much that the foods of the future will be unrecognizable to us, but the means by which they are grown will be potentially totally different from the way that foods have been grown in our lifetimes.

That's Amanda Little author of the book the fate of food what will eat in a bigger hotter smarter world you can watch her full talk at Ted.com. Thank you so much for listening to our show today called the food connection to learn more about the people who were on this episode go to Ted.NPR.org and to see hundreds more Ted talks check out Ted.com or the Ted app. If you've been enjoying the show we would be so grateful if you left us a review on apple podcasts it is the best way for us to reach new listeners which we are really trying to do. This episode was produced by Katie Monteleone, Fiona Geiran and Rachel Faulkner, Diba Mohtasham, and Sylvie Douglis. It was edited by Sanaz Meshkinpour and James Delahoussayee. Our production staff at NPR also includes Jeff Rogers Matthew crewTA and Harrison Vijay Troy our audio engineer is Daniel shook in. our theme music was written by Ron teen Arab Louis our partners at Ted are Chris Anderson Colin Helms Anna Phelan Michelle Clint and hiking. I'm Manoush Zomorodi and you've been listening to the Ted radio hour from NPR.

Hey, it's Manoush here. It has been shocking to watch the Russian invasion of Ukraine happen live on TV and social media. It's also kind of shocking that Russians are seeing a completely different version of the war play out full of fabricated images videos and suppose it facts. Disinformation and propaganda have always been part of any geopolitical conflict but now of course it's all over the internet and any of us can fall victim to it. That's why we want to revisit our episode called warped reality this week. It's about how some high tech deceptions get produced and why some people believe them. It's a show that's perfect to listen to or listen to again as once more we are glued to the headlines. I'll be back next week with a brand new episode meanwhile thanks so much for being here. Oh, and before we get started quick note this episode makes a couple references to sexual violence which might be hard for some listeners to hear.

This is the Ted radio hour. Each week groundbreaking Ted talks, “Our job now is to dream big.” delivered at Ted conferences “To bring about the future we want to see.” around the world “To understand who we are.” from those talks we bring you speakers and ideas that will surprise you, “You just don't know what you're gonna find.” challenge you, “Retrieved acts ourself like why is that noteworthy.” and even change you. “I literally feel like I'm a different person.” Yes. “Do you feel that way?” Ideas worth spreading. From Ted. and NPR.

I'm Manoush Zomorodi and on the show today technology and deception. The word deception has particular meaning. Deception is the intentional falsehood that is there is something done to manipulate help people feel in the world. It's designed to change people's behavior and mislead. This is Danielle Citron she's a professor of law at the university of Virginia where she teaches privacy and free speech and also researches tech and cyber harassment. And one of the best examples of this she says is the story of a woman named Ron Iube.

It was the 20 second fall 4/20/18 you know

Ronna Iube is an investigative journalist in India who has expose human rights abuses and government corruption

...you know I am somebody who say it's 1 of the most important ministers in the Modi government behind bars in 2010 and that's mine now happens to be the second most powerful man in India.

And in April of 2018 she received an email from a source inside the Modi government and the person said heads up a video is going around about you.

It was like a 2 minute 20 seconds porn video with my image all of it.

it was a fake sex video. And I mean she's got big brown eyes it looked like her that was Rana no question about it

When I got that video I said like I was humiliated, I was shamed by the people who want to discredit me

And it went viral. Speech also the video all over my social media on Instagram walks out messages and call what's all over India

Within 40 8:00 hours it's been reported that it was on like half of the phones in India

Before I knew it was on my father's phone my brother's phone.

Within a day after that her home address her cell phone number all over the internet. They were fake ads on adults like finder sites saying that she was available for sex and this is where she lives she was inundated with death and rape threats

I think it was as good as dead for the next 5 days since I received the video

And she pretty much didn't leave her house for like 6 months.

And I kept asking my friend I said what have I done to deserve this.

She became like a shell of herself.

And so how did how was that video made possible if it wasn't her. What was it?

It was a deepfake her face was inserted into a porn clip off so you know when I first worked on it you know what we knew what we knew about it was that you could insert faces into videos and and use sophisticated neural networks to do that you know it's called generative adversarial networks sort of insert a video and then find mistakes and keep iterating so that it becomes pretty perfected, but even that's a 2 years ago you could sort of tell though you know like if you stared at it enough that wasn't as good as Pixar it wasn't as good as you know the Lucas films and over time what we've seen is that now we can create from hold digital whole cloth video showing you doing and saying things that you never did or sad and they're really hard to tell with the human eye that it's just not manufactured right. And so Irona it was a perfect example of and the first one I had heard out of a deep fake sex video being used to basically drive someone out of the marketplace of ideas.

So if I go on one of these platforms right now like what's the likelihood that I will come across a deep fake or are we talking about a future that we're careening towards.

I'm largely imagining a terrible future but there's it's pretty bad here now let me let me explain. A group called Sancity they found that a year ago there are 15000 deepfake videos online and of those 150, 96 percent were deep fake sex videos and 99 percent of those 96 percent were of women's faces uncertain support. Wow. yes for 2 just a year later. 50000 deepfake videos again same line up right mostly over 90 percent deepfake sex videos and again same line up mostly all of women whose faces are being inserted into porn without their permission and it's not just U. S. women, you know, they found that it was women from all over the world. Like I guess women's images have been altered and air brush for so long and in some sense we're already surrounded by fake images everywhere but this is clearly taking into a homeowner there disturbing level.

Yep yep my eyes are absolutely nothing new to the human condition but what makes this phenomenon different is sort of 2 things coming together and the first is that we have this human frailty where audio and video have this power over us especially you know what we see so that we see something we're gonna believe it what's new is that we're in an online environment in which online platforms their business model their incentives is to accelerate share an insure that we make things go viral because then we're liking clicking and sharing and they're making money off of online advertising. And so their business model is aligned with our worst instincts.

Information travels faster and farther than ever and it does much more than just sparked elation or outrage. It changes what we believe. Conspiracy theories new kinds of audio and video and algorithms working behind the scenes make knowing what's true or false harder and harder. Our sense of reality is warping. We can see the consequences a deep distrust in each other and our fundamental institutions like democracy. So today on the show technology deception and ideas about what we can do to bring ourselves back to reality. Because as Danielle Citron says it takes just a trick of the human eye to up end someone's deeply held beliefs.

Deepfakes appear authentic and realistic but they're not they're total falsehoods

Daniel continues from the Ted stage

Now with the interaction of some of our most basic human frailties and network tools that can turn deepfakes into weapons so let me explain. As human beings we have a visceral reaction to audio and video we believe they're true on the notion that of course you can believe what your eyes and ears are telling you. And it's that mechanism that might undermine our shared sense of reality although we believe deep fakes to be true than not. And we're attracted to the salacious the provocative. We tend to believe in to share information that's a negative and novel, and researchers have found that online hoaxes spread 10 times faster than accurate stories. We're also drawn to information that aligns with our viewpoints. Psychologists call that tendency confirmation bias. And social media platforms supercharge that tendency by allowing us to instantly and widely share information that accords with our viewpoints.

Okay so all that information leads us to believe things whether they are indeed facts or lies but what about the people who say that they have the right to produce deepfakes or spread other misinformation because of the first amendment free speech

It's it's an odd misunderstanding both of first amendment doctrine and free speech very right because not all ones and zeros and words are protected speech as a matter of first amendment law and and matter of free speech values right why do we protect protect free speech because it helps us figure out how to govern ourselves because the Jews sort themselves out in the marketplace of ideas, because it helps us engage in self expression because it's a safety value is so many reasons why the reasons the out all those reasons that we can add more you know we got a few more. But when it comes to defamatory falsehoods let's take the deepfake video of showing someone doing and saying something they never did. As a matter of first amendment doctrine which show that kind of speech if you with actual malice spread a fake video of a public official doing and saying something they never did but you know it's false. You can be sued for that right so much and I've been writing about the stuff for a long time in my book hate crimes in cyberspace kind of explore how you know these online tools. It is all just the public square you know this record has a series of silly kind of you know this is understanding of the internet as like as if it's still 1996 right like it's all the town square and we're all town criers, that's foolish. What we're doing online is were working were hustling for clients were spreading ideas we are finding love ones right we are exploring ideas we are doing everything that we do offline we do it online. Because phones are wherever we are and so the idea that everything that happens online is protected free speech is wrong and it's not good for free speech values so the deepfakes sex video Ironna guess what it ended up with her off line and silenced. You know you're nude photo appears in a search of your name you are offline you take down this is just my experience working with victims you literally take down L. of your presence online

You're basically canceled for something that you didn't do

That's right. Your private persona becomes your public persona in an unwilling way that destroys your public persona. And it's so easy for people to say it's free speech and you know I will often get the push back. Often from people who are privileged so white men love yeah but they say will say to me like you know Danielle like you're you're approved why make such a big deal about nude photos we should all just put our nudes online. And I use them to take a beat I'm calm right I don't get mad. I'm so glad you're going to make that choice but I'm not going to make that choice right because it's going to cost me and other women, women of color, transgender, gay men trans men you know by folks like where folks it's just going to cost them more.

In a minute Daniel Citron Ahn Y. deepfakes have the potential to undermine our democracy. On the show today technology deception and are changing sense of reality I'm M Z and you're listening to the Ted radio hour from NPR. Stay with us.

This message comes from NPR sponsored Ted health a podcast where Ted speakers answer questions about health you never knew you had like can we edit memories how do we eat real meat without harming animals you'll learn about a smart bra for better heart health. 3 ways to prepare for the next pandemic and more find Ted health wherever you listen.

In stressful times you want to spend your time checking out not just what's best but what's best for you we know you care about what you watch what you read and what you listen to. NPR's pop culture happy hour podcast is with you 5 days a week to make sure that time is well spent listen now to the pop culture happy hour podcast from NPR.

It's the Ted radio hour from NPR I'm Manoush Zomorodi. We were just hearing lawyer and privacy expert Danielle citron described a recent internet phenomenon videos called deepfakes.

Walk with me into the future where we are in a place where we don't know whether to believe anything we see. what is that like.

So that's what we call that the liars dividends. In a world in which we can't tell the difference between what's fake and what's real. That's a real boon to the mischief makers and the liars. Because they got to point to real evidence of their wrong doing. And say it's not true and gets to walk away from responsibility and accountability for bad things that they've done and we've seen illustrations of this

yeah what a medically objected to beautiful I just start kissing them it's like a magnet

After the access Hollywood tape came out president trump said you know half said that I'm sorry

This was locker room talk I'm not proud of it I apologize to my family I apologize ...

you're later he shared with a reporter. She wasn't me on the access Hollywood tape. You sort of throwing out the layers dividend maybe to work right now for the most part that didn't really have great traction. And it's kind of part of his brand all of that so that you know the liars dividend like he tried it didn't work and maybe that didn't hurt him it didn't matter. But in an environment, in which we are sort of post truth so that we're gonna believe falsehoods if the accord with what we believe and we're going to disbelieve true if they don't accord with what we think you know confirmation bias then we're in this kind of post truth environment. And I never thought I would say this about our own country but political discourse feels fragile in a way that makes me feel like we're much more like a Myanmar than we are you know Canada. We don't feel like on solid ground in terms of discourse and so in this environment it feels so fragile our democracy.

As we see what happens in terms of the platforms taking responsibility or laws passed or whatever sort of systemic change may or may not happen I mean how much of us each of us as individuals who go online a lot. Do we have what's our responsibility to maybe I don't know sometimes I say to people like you know you are up against massive corporations when you like and share and all that stuff you're being manipulated but but maybe you see it differently maybe you think that we each have to do a better job as well.

We do you know in in in the here the now where there aren't laws right there are very few state laws around deep you know digital forgeries. We are the guardian at the gate platforms are going to do it for us do you like we can't we can't expect platforms whose incentives are to share because that's where their money is. it's on us each and everyone of us we need to protect ourselves and our democracy it's ours as it's ours to lose. So I do think we have a huge role. What I'm asking is so modest. Think before you click and share. Ask yourself is this likely and it was really crazy don't you think that it's fake. You know that's why it's there right it's there because it's negative and novels It's there 2 feet on our salacious curiosity. Don't do it.

That's Danielle Citron she's a professor of law at the university of Virginia where she teaches and writes about privacy and free speech you can see her full talk at ted.com. On the show today ideas about technology deception and are changing sense of reality. And deep fakes make up one disturbing side of misinformation another conspiracy theories. Sure they've been around a long time classics like the earth is flat or another one that just won't go away.

There's a secret club all of China we will see a leads to either explicitly are named as Jews or just kind of fit into tight all molds that sounds like they're probably Jews.

In the past few years these conspiracy theories along with a whole set of new ones have moved from the extreme fringes into the American mainstream.

If ever there were questions whether a deep state exists it is real folks and you got your answer this week George Soros is behind all of this ... With the global warming and that that is a lot of it's a hoax it's a hoax I mean it's a money making video they will be advancing their new conspiracy theory and their newest hoax one recent example an ... online conspiracy theory it's unclear if it was when I came in on space list conspiracy theories have been repeatedly to bomb despite this the far right group continues to network of conspiracy theories all leading back to a mistake anonymous leader named Q. allegedly a high level government official who has access to top secret information.

Well I don't know much about the movement other than I understand they liked me very much. Which I appreciate but I don't know much about the movement

yes so. Q. anon starts with the assumption that Donald Trump is secretly saving the world and that you know he doesn't want credit for it he doesn't want to boast about it but he's actually the only person who is ferreting out this massive deep state conspiracy that involves hundreds of people engaging and child sex trafficking and satanic cannibalistic rituals. What it's like to sorry what. And you know that is just straight up misinformation slash disinformation so in a way that's almost a less ambiguous case because it's so completely bonkers honestly and it's almost like if I were writing the script I would be like nahh guys that's too on the nose like that's too bad that's it's too much of a leave that bizarre yes no 1 will believe it but you know millions of people do.

This is journalist Andrew Marantz

I am staff writer at The New Yorker magazine and so I wrote a book called anti social makes remember the subtitle online extremists techno utopians and the hijacking of the American conversation.

Even before Q. anon entered mainstream conversation in 2017 intra noticed a huge rise in far right extremism and conspiracy theories online

Starting in 2014 or 2015 around there I started seeing this informational crisis on the horizon I certainly was not the only person but I was kind of behind the curve at the time because I wasn't back then thinking of this as a particularly political story I was thinking of it as you know a business story or a tech story or yeah but then the summer of 2016 I really started saying okay this is going to have a massive impact on the presidential election in a way how could it not right. Racist memes misogynist propaganda viral misinformation so I wanted to know who is making this stuff I wanted to understand how they were spreading it ultimately I wanted to know what kind of impact it might be having on our society

Aere's Andrew on the Ted stage.

So that's how I ended up in the living room of a social media propagandists in southern California he was a married a white guy in his late thirties he had a a table in front of him with a mug of coffee a laptop for tweeting, a phone for texting an iPad for live streaming to periscope and YouTube, and yet with those tools he was able to propel his fringe noxious talking points into the heart of the American conversation. For example one of the days I was there a bomb had just exploded in New York. And the guy accused of planting the bomb had a Muslim sounding name. Now to the propagandist in California this seems like an opportunity. Because one of the things he wanted was for the US to cut off almost all immigration especially from Muslim majority countries so he started live streaming getting his followers worked up into a frenzy about how to open borders agenda was going to kill us all and asking him to tweet about this and your specific hashtags trying to get those hashtags trending in tweet baited hundreds and hundreds of tweets.

It must be kind of weird for you like sitting there and watching how public manipulation works from a couch.

Yeah what what you see when you sort of sit at someone's elbow and watch them do this is it's like getting good at poker or something you kind of learn the basic mechanics of the thing and then you play a lot of rounds and if you're good enough you know you don't win every round but you went a lot of so what that means in terms of social media is you cannot get a sense of what the algorithms wants and the really simplistic way of putting it is that they want whatever has the sharpest emotional impact on the viewer and specific kinds of emotions too the motions that make people do something with their either click or share but for the most part he wasn't breaking the rules of Twitter or whatever platform he was using he was just really good at getting his message out there.

So this guy in California and all the other folks he spent time with like what was their mission was it just to create chaos to tear down democracy because that guy doesn't seem like he really believes in the stuff but there are people who do.

yeah it's a spectrum right it's it's sometimes we talk about you know people who are doing this for profit cynically who don't believe what they're peddling and then people on the other hand who are true believers and I think that is a true and worthwhile distinction and I guess all I would add is that there are many shades of gray in between. right so it's not purely immediate monetary motivation in most cases and then you'll get some cases where it is just people who have just been radicalized or you know read billed as they call it and they just think the world will not be safe until we have a white ethnostate and you know obviously those people are hard to deal with because they're pretty far gone. I talked a lot with one young woman who grew up in New Jersey. And then after high school she moved to a new place and suddenly she just felt alienated and cut off and started retreating into the phone. She found some of the spaces on the internet where people would post the most shocking heinous things and she found the stuff really off putting but also kind of engrossing started interacting with people in these online spaces and they made her feel smart meter feel validated she started feeling a sense of community started wondering if maybe some of these shocking memes might actually contain a kernel of truth. A few months later she was in a car with some of her new internet friends headed to Charlottesville Virginia to March with torches in the name of the white race. She gone a few months from Obama supporter to fully radicalized white supremacist.

Okay so for those of us who just can't wrap our heads around how someone's ideas about the world can change so rapidly “right” how does that happen especially with something like Q. anon which is really an entire mind set

Yes so it's sort of like any call to you know you start with the stuff that sounds less controversial and then the more and more people get initiated the more they're prepared to believe more and more outlandish things so you kind of start with parts of it that are closer to the truth like there was this guy Jeffrey Epstein who was really was doing all kinds of outrageously terrible things and he really was friends with Bill Clinton and prince Andrew and “you right” out there really was a conspiracy to cover up those crimes that is still on going and then you kind of go from there to you know I bet Hillary was involved in I also bet Tom Hanks was involved in it at Oprah's probably involved and they all have a dungeon somewhere where they're locking up children and trying to harvest their adrenal glands and

okay you lost me with the adrenal glands

well I I think when you start going down that rabbit hole part of it is engaging in a kind of collective fan fiction and part of it is we'll wait but what if this is real and it's flirting with that line and you know I can get that to some extent I get the thrill of being like what is. there really was a an Illuminati and it's just to a certain kind of person at a certain desperate moment in their lives or just spend too much time on the internet they they can't keep those blurry lines straight and it becomes their entire reality

I can understand how in a time of financial problems in security this idea of being part of a movement and having meaning in your life and being you know part of like the revolution on Ritesh actually that's that's very exciting yes the underground

part of the resistance and have. In secret knowledge that no one else can see except for your compadres yet it's just bizarre how far it can go

And some of these troops are you know he is centuries old and dumb ways they're not new

Yeah I did not expect the fact that I am Jewish to matter in any way I didn't expect to be talking about things like protocols of the elders of Zion and like mine constant stuff I thought frankly that they would be a little more original than that but as it turns out there are certain tropes that just refused to go away, and it does a lot of work for people it helps explain things that are otherwise unexplainable, you know, why is the economy so obviously you seem to be rigged against me why can't I find meaningful work or why do I have to work but I still don't feel like my life has any purpose light you know on and on and on with these kind of sometimes unanswerable questions and if the answer is because there are 10 people in a room somewhere saying I don't want people to have meaning in their lives and then in a way that's kind of a comforting explanation because it it it means that there's at least a namable reason or a an identifiable enemy. And often that's Jews often that's women often it's just whoever's a visible other in terms of being a person of color or what have you. But I think one of the notable things for me is not that these troops still exist in the world but the fact that they can be revived in terms of popularity and in terms of salience to the national discourse that that I did find surprising.

I mean it feels as though this idea that a single person switching on a story that changes people's perception of what reality even is has become so commonplace that we are in the midst of an error very little trust

Yes. It is common place now and the companies have had a lot of time to try to figure this out in some ways they have you know it is no longer okay on Facebook to buy an ad in an American election using rubles as the. That was a loophole that was opened in 2016 that should not have been open but it was. They did close that loophole but the larger loophole which is the entire incentive structure the entire thing that social media is built to do that hasn't changed and yes as a result we are living in a pretty confused and confusing time

So what do we do in the meantime like how do we fix this at least a little bit

Yes so a lot of the bigger solutions to this are going to have to be systemic and the companies are going to have to step up and it might involve government regulation and all kinds of bigger things but until they rebuild and dismantle their business model there are things that individuals can do when one of them I call it being a smart skeptic so there are things that pass for skepticism online that I think I actually just need jerk contrarian troll arrays so you often see people saying well I'm just asking for more evidence and I'm just asking the question, but that is not real skepticism in real skepticism is being open minded but not being so open minded that your brain is also demanding evidence but not demanding evidence past the time when a question has been settled. If you just sort of say well I don't know you know everybody says racism is bad but like I'm skeptical of that claim I don't think skepticism is the best word for what you're doing there and sometimes they're just is consensus on something and there's a certain cast of mind of a person who just doesn't want to hear that. It's a kind of addiction to feeling like you have secret access to the knowledge that you know the countries of polite society doesn't want you to have.

If only we all had that secret accessory

yeah I mean it's a thrilling idea it's just that sometimes the real answer is the answer that most people already believe and I'm sorry if that's boring but it's just sometimes is the case.

That's Andrew Marantz. he's a journalist and staff writer for The New Yorker you can see his full talk at Ted.com. On the show today technology and deception I'm a new summer roadie and you're listening to the Ted radio hour from NPR.

This message comes from NPR sponsor work life a podcast from Ted where organizational psychologist Adam grant explores the science of making work not suck. In the new season you'll learn about that not so great resignation and how to retain employees. You'll discover how to wrestle with perfectionism how to master a pitch and more find a work life with Adam grants were ever you listen. This message comes from NPR sponsor work life a podcast from Ted where organizational psychologist Adam grant explores the science of making work not suck in the new season you'll learn about that not so great resignation and how to retain employees you'll discover how to wrestle with perfectionism how to master rip hitch and more. Find a work life with Adam grants were ever you listen.

It's the Ted radio hour from NPR I'm Manoush Zomorodi. on the show today technology deception and are changing sense of reality. And so far we've been talking about deepfakes conspiracy theories and other kinds of misinformation the data and algorithms they can board a reality too

We can deceive ourselves into thinking they're not doing hardware we can fool ourselves into thinking because it's based on numbers that it is somehow neutral. A. I. is creeping into our lives and even though the promises that's going to be more efficient it's going to be better if what's happening is we're automating inequality through weapons of mass destruction and we have algorithms of oppression this promise is not actually true and certainly not true for everybody.

Weapons of mass destruction algorithms of oppression which basically means bias and human error can be encoded into algorithms leading to inequality to keep them in check the algorithmic justice league to the rest.

My name is Joy Buolamwini I'm the founder of the algorithmic justice league where we use our research and art to create a world with more equitable and accountable A.I. You might have heard of the male gaze or the white gaze or the post colonial gaze to that lacks the god I add the coded gaze the ad that we want to make sure people are even aware of it because you can't fight the power you don't see you don't know about.

Joy hunts down the flaws in the technology that's running every part of our lives from deciding what we see on Instagram to how we might be sentenced for a crime

What happens when somebody is harmed by a system you created you know what happens if your heart where do you go we want that kind of place to be the algorithmic justice league so you can seek redress of for algorithmic harms

You are a lot of things you're a poet you're at a computer scientist you are a super hero like. Hard to put into a box and can you just explain why you created the algorithmic justice league

Yes so the algorithmic justice league is a bit of an accident when I was in graduate school I was working on an art project that use some computer vision technology to track my face “hi camera I thank. Can you see my face” at least that was the idea you can see her face. And when I tried to get it to work on my face I found that putting up white mask on my dark skin. Is what I needed in order to have the system ahh pick me up and so that led to questions about where our machines neutral why do I need to change myself to be seen by a machine and if this is using A.I. techniques that are being used in other areas of our lives whether it's health or education transportation the criminal justice system what does that mean if different kinds of mistakes are being made, and also even if the systems do work well let's say you are able to track of face perfectly what does that mean for surveillance what does it mean for democracy first amendment rights you know.

Joy continues from the Ted stage

Across the U. S. police departments are starting to use facial recognition software in their crime fighting arsenal Georgetown law published a report showing not whining into adults in the U. S. that's 117000000 people have their faces and facial recognition networks. Police departments can currently look at these networks I'm regulated using algorithms that have not been audited for accuracy. Machine learning is being used for facial recognition but it's also extending beyond the realm of computer vision. So who gets hired or fired you get that loan you get insurance are you a minute into the college that you wanted to get into do you and I pay the same price for the same product purchased on the same platform. Law enforcement is also starting to use machine learning for predictive policing. Some judges use machine generated arrest scores to determine how long an individual is going to spend in prison. So we really have to think about these decisions are they fair, and we've seen that algorithmic bias doesn't necessarily always lead to fair outcomes.

When I think about algorithmic bias and people ask me well what do you mean machines are biased it's just numbers in just the data I talk about machine learning and it's a question of well what is the machine learning from well what is the machine learning from like what's the information that it's taking in

So an example of this what I found was that for face detection and the ways in which systems were being trained involved collecting large data sets of images of human faces and when you look at those data sets I found that many of them were pale and male right you might have a data set that 75 percent on male faces over 80 percent lighter skinned faces and so what it means is that the machine is learning a representation of the world that is skewed. And so what you might have thought should be a neutral process is actually reflecting the bias sees that it has been a train dogs and sometimes what you're seeing is a skewed representation but other times what machines are picking up on our our own societal biases that are actually true to those data

For example Amazon was building a hiring tool

You need a job somebody in your life needs a job. Right you want to get hired

and to get hired you upload your resume in your cover letter

that's the goal it starts off well

but before human looks at your resume gets vetted by algorithms written by software engineers

so we that we start off with that it and then Ted for efficiency we have many more applications than any human could go through let's create a system that can do it more efficiently than we can

and how to build that better system

well we're going to gather data of it resumes and we're going to sort those resumes by the ones that represented candidates we hired or did well your target is who you think will be a good long term employee

And now the system gets trained on the data

and the system is learning from prior data so I like to say the past wells within our algorithms. You don't have to have the sexes hiring manager in front of you now you have a black box that serving as the gatekeeper but what it's learning are the patterns of what success has looked like in the past so for defining success by how would look like in the past in the past has been one where men were given opportunities white people who were given opportunity and you don't necessarily fit that profile even though you might think you're creating this objective system it's going through resumes right this is where we run into problems.

So here's what happened with Amazon's hiring tool

What happened was as the model was being built and it was being tested what they found was a gender bias where resumes that contained the word women or women or even an all women's colleges right so in the case of being a woman were categorically being rank lower than those that did it and try as they might they were not able to remove that gender bias so they ended up scratching the system.

They scratch the system and that's a big win but one win compared to thousands of platforms that use skewed algorithms that could warp reality

It is not been the case that we had universal equality or absolute equality in the words of Frederick Douglass and and I I specially worry about this when we think about techno benevolence in the space of health care. Right we're looking at let's see a breakthrough that comes in talking about skin care skin cancer we now have an A. I. system right that cannot classify skin cancer as well as the top dermatologists the study might say a headline might read and then when you look at it's like oh well actually when you look at the data set that it was for lighter skinned individuals. You might argue well you don't like your skin people are more likely to get skin cancer and when I was looking into this it actually darker skinned people who get skin cancer usually has to tap into the stage 4 because they're all of these assumptions are not even going to get it in the first place. So these assumptions can have a meaningful consequences.

You know we weren't just talking before about the 2016 presidential election have you seen any examples of artificial intelligence being used in voting more more politics

yes Sir channel 4 news just did this massive investigation showing that the 2016 trump campaign targeted 3.5000000 African Americans in the United States labeled them as deterrents into an attempt to actually keep people from showing up to the polls

They used targeted ads

yes and we know we know from Facebook's own research right that you can influence voter turn now based on the kinds of posts that are put on their platform. And they did this in battleground states and so in this way we're seeing predictive modeling and I had targeting right being used as a tool of voter suppression which has always been the case to disenfranchise right, you might say black lives don't matter but it's clear black votes matter because of so much effort used to rob people of what the blood was spilt for hero for generations. so it shouldn't be the case right that any sorts of algorithmic tools that are intended to be used again have to be verified for non discrimination before it's even adopted by

So as a black woman technologist you know there's not that many of you frankly why not you know go work at Google or Amazon and make these changes to the algorithms directly why act as sort of a watchdog.

I think there are multiple ways to be involved in the ecosystem but I do think this question you pose it's really important because it can be an assumption that by changing who's in the room which is an important and needs to happen we're going to change the outcome and the output of the system so I like to remind people that most software developers engineers computer sciences you don't build everything from scratch right you you got reusable parts and so if there's a bias within those reusable parts or large scale bias in the data sets that have become standard practice or the status quo right changing the people who are involved in the system without changing the system itself is still going to reproduce algorithmic bias and algorithmic harms so how do we build systems that are more fair like if there's no data for the artificial intelligence to sort of you know process to to start to pump out recommendations then then how do we even change that yeah well it's a question of a what tools do you use towards what objectives so the first thing is seeing if this is the appropriate tool not every told not every decision needs to be run through A. I. and oftentimes you also need to make sure your being intentional and so the kind rate changes you would need to make systematically for even who gets into the job pool in general it means you do have to change society to change what A.I. is learning.

What do you say join it to people who list might be listening and thinking like you know you ... let's let's take take a step back in there and look at the bigger picture we in in many ways things are way better than they were in thanks to technology because you know here we are in a pandemic and anyone can work from anywhere because we have the internet and we M. zoom in all these platforms equality and access is on the whole improved why let's let's not think be Debbie downers about it.

Yeah I mean I always ask who can afford to say that because I can tell you the kids were sitting in McDonald's parking lot so they can access the internet to be able to attend school remotely that has never been a their reality and so often times if you are able to say technology on the whole has done well it probably means you're in a fairly privileged position there's still a huge digital divide even their billions of people who don't have access to the internet I mean I was born in Canada move to god and then grew up in the U.S. I had very western assumptions you know about what tech could do I'm very much excited to use the tech skills I've gained as a undergrad at George's pack you know to use tech for good for the benefit of humanity and so when I critique tactic it's really coming from a place of having been enamored it with that and wanting it to live up to its promises. I don't think it's a being a Debbie Downer to show ways in which we can improve so the promise of something we've created can actually be realized I think that's even a more optimistic approach than to believe in a wishful thinking that is not true

You know one thing that you said that I I find so I love this idea that that you see there's a difference between potential and reality and that we must separate those two ideas

Yes so it's so easy to fix the aid on our aspirations of what could be it and I think in some ways this this hope that we can transcend up our own humanity right our own failures and so yes even if we haven't gotten society quite right ideally we can build technology that better than we are but we then have to look at that that that technology reflects who we are it doesn't transcend who we are and so I think it's important that when we think about technology we ask what's the promise, what's the reality and not only what's that got but who does it work for who does it benefit who does it harm and why, and also how do we then step up and stand up to those harms.

That's Joy Buolamwini founder of the algorithmic justice league you can watch her full talk at ted.com. Thank you so much for listening to our show this week about technology deception and are warped reality to learn more about the people who were on it go to ted.NPR.org and to see hundreds more Ted talks check out ted.com or the Ted app. Our Ted radio production staff at NPR includes Jeff Rogers son as Michigan poor Rachel Faulkner deep emotion James Dale who C. J. C. Howard Katie Monteleone Maria Paz Gutierrez Christina Kala and Matthew crew TA with help from Daniel shook in our intern is fair at safari our theme music was written by rom teen era Bluey our partners at Ted are Chris Anderson Colin Helms Anna Phelan and Michelle Quint. I'm Manoush Zomorodi and you've been listening to the Ted radio hour from NPR.